Jizz

I like bigger things, but a sharpie will do...

ButtSharpies

Taste the rainbow

ButtSharpies

I hope you guys like it.

ButtSharpies

Nice spread, not quite a sharpie

ButtSharpies

A little bit of fuzz

ButtSharpies

13 Sharpies! To the top with her!

ButtSharpies

How do you all like my cute butthole?

ButtSharpies

Chubby girl on her bed

ButtSharpies

bought these and a bottle of vodka for my girl. wish me luck.

ButtSharpies

Hog Tied [F]or Sharpie & Spanking

ButtSharpies

[META] My deals app certainly knows my interests... (x-post from /r/funny)

ButtSharpies

[Self] A butt sharpie for a dare. All for you Andy

ButtSharpies

Some one... is trying to promote this subreddit (potatoe quality)

ButtSharpies

Rule 23 - Sunday

ButtSharpies

Rule 23 - Monday

ButtSharpies

Rule 23 - Wednesday

ButtSharpies

Rule 23 - Thursday

ButtSharpies

Rule 23 - Friday

ButtSharpies

I am a sharpie sissy! Kik: kent_daivey

ButtSharpies

15 in my booty, 15 in my pussy. is this a record? [self]

ButtSharpies

Does a toothbrush count?

ButtSharpies

(F) it was requested i submit here... 8 on the first try

ButtSharpies

Babby's First Anal

ButtSharpies

21!

ButtSharpies

[self] first time with a sharpie

ButtSharpies

24 Sharpies in the Booty - Explosion GIF [Self]

ButtSharpies

Got 9 in there today (self)

ButtSharpies

Just one this time (f)irst time

ButtSharpies

Gf butt sharpie

ButtSharpies

A fellow redditor managed 9 on the first try.

ButtSharpies

Just two.

ButtSharpies

SIX on my [F]irst try!

ButtSharpies

Got the new Sharpie megapack!! Any girl in the PDX area want to try??

ButtSharpies

14 - Was instructed to post pics of increasing number each week until I can fist my asshole.

ButtSharpies

Too small for insertion? (F)

ButtSharpies

Another shot of my wife's first!

ButtSharpies

Five for now :p

ButtSharpies

Interested in seeing more Sharpies ?

ButtSharpies

I glanced at this reminder and my brain saw “Butt Sharpies.”

ButtSharpies

Look what my girl bought us after I showed her this sub ?

ButtSharpies

Challenge round anyone?

ButtSharpies

Unfortunately I Only Had 10 Available

ButtSharpies

Variety is the spice of life

ButtSharpies

It's not my butthole but I think this is equally impressive

ButtSharpies

[F]irst time. Not bad out of the gate. Album in comments.

ButtSharpies

[oc] just one and two

ButtSharpies

first one!~

ButtSharpies

[self] 14 sharpies. Working up to getting my fist in my asshole.

ButtSharpies

Starter pack!

ButtSharpies

Five for my first time.:)

ButtSharpies

? Anyone into big tits?

ButtSharpies

How do you ensure that the sharpies are not getting lost in you?

ButtSharpies

love it when I insert it deep ? (f)

ButtSharpies

pardon her photography skills.

ButtSharpies

16 isn't too bad for [M]y first try!

ButtSharpies

9

ButtSharpies

my after school activity ? (18)

ButtSharpies

[OC] May I lend a helping sharpie ?

ButtSharpies

She can only get one in so far but she tells me she's working on more.

ButtSharpies

Imgur

ButtSharpies