Jizz

Two in the front, two in the back

ButtSharpies

I don't even think that's a Sharpie!

ButtSharpies

Rainbow

ButtSharpies

One in the pink, one in the stink

ButtSharpies

Black & blue

ButtSharpies

I don't think this is right...

ButtSharpies

Not a sharpie, but close enough.

ButtSharpies

Two Moon and a Hammy

ButtSharpies

3 sharpies in the butt

ButtSharpies

Where would we be without you, /b/

ButtSharpies

Plenty of ass

ButtSharpies

A nice view

ButtSharpies

Did someone ask for grey?

ButtSharpies

Some girls just can't get enough of sharpies

ButtSharpies

Post-it note

ButtSharpies

Truly a sight to behold

ButtSharpies

Not quite a Sharpie, butt.....

ButtSharpies

Just a marker, not a Sharpie:(

ButtSharpies

Sharpie in butt cheeks

ButtSharpies

Hog Tied [F]or Sharpie & Spanking

ButtSharpies

A little yella' for the fellas

ButtSharpies

Never tried sharpies before. How'd I do?

ButtSharpies

Found a random Sharpie in the bathroom and I'm not the only redditor in the house...

ButtSharpies

I know it's hard to see but I got 14 on my first try!!

ButtSharpies

Rule 23 - Tuesday

ButtSharpies

6.

ButtSharpies

Was told to post this here

ButtSharpies

Guess what's about to go down! Watch for pics!

ButtSharpies

[F]irst attempt with butt sharpies. Sweet 16?

ButtSharpies

5 large 1 regular

ButtSharpies

Sel(f) 1st time post and try!

ButtSharpies

a comic inspired by this site

ButtSharpies

Challenge round anyone?

ButtSharpies

sry bout quality

buttsharpie

This got in my Facebook feed. I say it fits nicely here.

ButtSharpies

Four My Peeps

ButtSharpies

Four My[self] and My Peeps

ButtSharpies

15, But can't get enough! more gi[f]s in comments!

ButtSharpies

[F18] thought I’d give this a try.. I’m at 5 right now.. should I go for more..? ??

ButtSharpies

What do y’all think? [OC]

ButtSharpies

[self] 14 sharpies. Working up to getting my fist in my asshole.

ButtSharpies

Coconut oil really helps

ButtSharpies

Punishment for not capitalizing Sir when addressing u/Bull1204

ButtSharpies

Imgur

ButtSharpies