Jizz

Two in the front, two in the back

ButtSharpies

I don't even think that's a Sharpie!

ButtSharpies

Rainbow

ButtSharpies

One in the pink, one in the stink

ButtSharpies

Black & blue

ButtSharpies

I don't think this is right...

ButtSharpies

Not a sharpie, but close enough.

ButtSharpies

Two Moon and a Hammy

ButtSharpies

Was told to post this here by GW 8)

ButtSharpies

Two sharpies and a little extra space

ButtSharpies

Wow time

ButtSharpies

3 sharpies in the butt

ButtSharpies

More Butt Sharpie

ButtSharpies

i wonder what else could fit...

ButtSharpies

Green... in her bum

ButtSharpies

Just one redhead

ButtSharpies

You seem to have something in your butt...

ButtSharpies

Where would we be without you, /b/

ButtSharpies

Red nails, blue sharpie

ButtSharpies

Plenty of ass

ButtSharpies

A nice view

ButtSharpies

Did someone ask for grey?

ButtSharpies

Some girls just can't get enough of sharpies

ButtSharpies

A new angle

ButtSharpies

Post-it note

ButtSharpies

Truly a sight to behold

ButtSharpies

Not quite a Sharpie, butt.....

ButtSharpies

Just a marker, not a Sharpie:(

ButtSharpies

Sharpie in butt cheeks

ButtSharpies

A little yella' for the fellas

ButtSharpies

Never tried sharpies before. How'd I do?

ButtSharpies

Found a random Sharpie in the bathroom and I'm not the only redditor in the house...

ButtSharpies

I know it's hard to see but I got 14 on my first try!!

ButtSharpies

Rule 23 - Tuesday

ButtSharpies

6.

ButtSharpies

First time trying anything like this. It felt exhilarating.

ButtSharpies

Was told to post this here

ButtSharpies

Guess what's about to go down! Watch for pics!

ButtSharpies

Masters wanted me to start training.

ButtSharpies

[F]irst attempt with butt sharpies. Sweet 16?

ButtSharpies

[self] Got four colors on my first try - shooting for the rainbow next time!!!

ButtSharpies

5 large 1 regular

ButtSharpies

Sel(f) 1st time post and try!

ButtSharpies

a comic inspired by this site

ButtSharpies

My First Time

ButtSharpies

sry bout quality

buttsharpie

This got in my Facebook feed. I say it fits nicely here.

ButtSharpies

Four My Peeps

ButtSharpies

Four My[self] and My Peeps

ButtSharpies

15, But can't get enough! more gi[f]s in comments!

ButtSharpies

[F18] thought I’d give this a try.. I’m at 5 right now.. should I go for more..? ??

ButtSharpies

What do y’all think? [OC]

ButtSharpies

[self] 14 sharpies. Working up to getting my fist in my asshole.

ButtSharpies

Coconut oil really helps

ButtSharpies

Just one (f)or now

ButtSharpies

Two-tone ..See my Profile :p

ButtSharpies

I'm going to ease myself into this.

ButtSharpies

Trying one first

ButtSharpies

Punishment for not capitalizing Sir when addressing u/Bull1204

ButtSharpies

Imgur

ButtSharpies