Jizz

"My Dishonest Heart" by Audrey Kawasaki customized. Details in comments. Tatoo done by Sharpie at Tattoo Lous, Bayshore, NY

tattoos

She wouldn't let me show the sharpie in her ass, but here's the picture

ButtSharpies

She wouldnt let me show the sharpie, but here's the picture

ButtSharpies

Average Number of Sharpies inserted from two years of posts from /r/buttsharpies [OC, NSFW]

dataisbeautiful, ButtSharpies

Request. Giant double sided sharpies.

ButtSharpies

First time Butt Sharpie. Be nice :)

ButtSharpies

A graph showing the most popular colours of sharpies on /r/buttsharpies

ButtSharpies

I should be taking notes but doodleing instead sharpie

doodles

Butt sharpie

ButtSharpies

How do I get sharpie off my skin [F]

gonewild

My butt sharpie [F]

ButtSharpies

Are [t]rans girl buttsharpies ok? There'd be some 20 or so more in there, but I only own one sharpie. :(

ButtSharpies

[vid] 10 minutes of playing with a Sharpie! $5

Sexsells

Mine and the misses fun collection (Sharpie for scale).

Pegging

My [M]iss made me put a sharpie in my butt and post it as punishment for being bad

ButtSharpies

I'm on a mission to lose weight. Every five pounds I'll add another sharpie. Started with 3, hope to hit 9 by the end of the year. Anyone want to help? Extra pics for those who help keep me working out. I may not have the perfect ass yet, but I'm gonna bu

ButtSharpies

[Self] So I'm down five pounds from my highest weight. That counts, right? In other news, I may be a bit of a sharpie slut.

ButtSharpies

[Self] So I'm a current poster to r/buttsharpies, where I'm posting a new pic (with an extra sharpie) for every five pounds I lose. Decided to prep for number 4 by doing my yoga routine with my favorite butt plug.

buttplug

I had an unaccountable urge to stick a Sharpie down my cock

sounding

Bound and butt sharpied

ButtSharpies, nsfwtop, Bondage

I told you to be quite, Sharpie, 12x9. NSFW

Art

A sharpie is all I can do...

assholegonewild

Having fun with a Sharpie! (X/post from r/femboys)

Sissies

(M)y first time posting something like this. Found a sharpie in my storage and couldn't resist the urge..

ButtSharpies

EDGY "Keep outta my Shit"message with 'un'COOL sharpie art..

ImGoingToHellForThis

[Self] Butt Sharpie Virgin, only one... Maybe more to cum? 20(f)

ButtSharpies

(x-post from r/LipsThatGrip) My pussy is so tight it grips a sharpie :)

RandomPornGifs

Guess How Many Sharpies I Can Fit In My Tight Asshole - Link In Comments [F, 20]

gonewild

NSFW - Grab a sharpie and write on your chick!

MilitaryGoneWild

What do you think of these veins? Close up and sharpie for reference.

MassiveCock

Am I really that small? sharpie for scale.

sph

I was told to put 4 sharpies in my ass and post it here.

ButtSharpies

Magnum Sharpie. What else would you guys like to put in there ;)

GaybrosGoneWild

[OC] Found my Sharpies

insertions

2 large Sharpies in [m]y ass

SharpieChallenge

Hey, look! Context! How many sharpies-widths do you prefer?

ThickDick

I like to get drunk and draw on myself with a sharpie ??‍♀️

GoneMild

Pink Sharpie in Pussy Doggy Style

TubBitches

Does this count? Sticking a sharpie in my butt.

GuysFingering, GuysFromBehind, manass, GaybrosGoneWild

would you rather the sharpie or my tiny dick?

sph

Count those sharpies

Balls, buttplug, ButtSharpies, GaybrosGoneWild

Just transitioning, how is my first time with a sharpie?

GoneWildTrans

28 sharpies - someone mentioned gif goes to quick - so stills from the video

SharpieChallenge

Is it gay if I enjoy the occasional sharpie in my asshole?

cock

Petite Girl Stretching Her Tight Little Pussy Out With Sharpie Pens

insertions

Bad quality so you can't see my scarred X to signify an end to self harm, but hey look at the sharpie bullshit^^

altgonewild, gonewild

A sharpie makes me wet!

AsianHotties

Sounds instead of sharpies. (Another angle)

Objects

22 [F] First time and managed 12 sharpies and a hairbrush...anyone think I can do more?

NotADildo, Objects, throwaway855836, SharpieChallenge

Finding a spot for the sharpie when you're done using it

Objects

Sometimes a sharpie is all it takes to get me dripping

Misogynyfetish

Sexual exploration = exhausted, sore boy ☺️ I'm up to 3 sharpies

twinks

a sharpie in her butt

NSFW_ASS

she put a sharpie up her ass

SexyAss

she put a sharpie up her ass

PoliticsNSFW

a sharpie in her butt

Real_Amateurs

she put a sharpie up her ass

ThinkTankSexy

I thought putting a bunch of sharpies in my butt would be easy - Cue the Benny Hill theme ??(OC)

AnalGW, anal

It was my brother's idea haha. 500 upvotes and he gets to shove as many sharpies possible into my butt :)

Slut, PetiteGoneWild, NSFWFunny, u_headfinder

I guess my 19f butthole doesn't like sharpies, oops haha

ButtSharpies, Slut, asshole, assholegonewild, u_JosephineTheDragonQ, adorableporn, anal, Amateur, nsfwhardcore, bigasses, u_lilrene777, u_Epicfaceless, insertions, Objects, DirtyConfession, u_galaxxxystar, u_kayman_777