Jizz

Many colours

ButtSharpies, funny

Schoolgirl

ButtSharpies, LizardMan

Black sharpie, red hair

ButtSharpies, GirlswithNeonHair

That's a big sharpie

ButtSharpies, analinsertions, anal

Xpost from r/gonewild & r/objects

ButtSharpies, gonewild, Objects

gingerpuss from r/gonewild

ButtSharpies, Gingerpuss

Garden State

ButtSharpies, nsfw

Three

ButtSharpies, gonewild

Double trouble

ButtSharpies, insertions

1 pink, 2 black

ButtSharpies, circlejerk

Hello [f]

ButtSharpies, gonewild

[hello] These have two uses, remember.

ButtSharpies, allofthebutts, WTF

[I] can Sharpie a rainbow, Sharpie a rainbow too!

ButtSharpies, AssSharpies

Just one

ButtSharpies, Fapucational

Really happy with one [x-post r/amateurteen]

ButtSharpies, AssQueen, cottontails

A Sharpie and a pen. Wish I could fit more. [f]

ButtSharpies, AnalGW

Trying [f]or the record. Only got to 15 this time. Maybe next time?

ButtSharpies, AnalGW

My try at sharpies. xpost from r/Analgw

ButtSharpies, gonewild, AnalGW

Blondie

ButtSharpies, dogcity

[F]20 - Only 7 here, but we got up to 13 that night. Still working on it!

ButtSharpies, AnalGW

One lonely sharpie

ButtSharpies, natejackett

I can't even tell how many there are...

ButtSharpies, RateHerBody

[Self] So I think my apple butt needs some shaping up. I'm going to add a sharpie for every five pounds I lose. Starting with three...let's see how many I can fit by the end of the year. :)

ButtSharpies, scrolller_com

My girlfriend can't take as many as I can, but you don't want to see me :P

ButtSharpies, anal

She's new at butt Sharpies but giving it her best

ButtSharpies, scrolller_com

Just 1 large Sharpie for now!

ButtSharpies, SharpieChallenge

[F]ist Post, pardon my photography skills.

ButtSharpies, assholegonewild, asshole, collegesluts, pawg, gonewild, PetiteGoneWild, SharpieChallenge

Convinced my[self] to try one in combination with my favorite toy

ButtSharpies, gonewild30plus

Two-tone

ButtSharpies, RateHerBody

Her first time, could only manage 1 ( xpost r/AsianSlutWife)

ButtSharpies, insertions, upherbutt

We got to 7 then ran out of sharpies :(

ButtSharpies, OurUniverse86

Pen In The Butt [PIC]

ButtSharpies, MasterOfAnal, SlutMeUp

Starting with 3. Can't wait to get my lesson with the ruler ?

ButtSharpies, OurUniverse86

Marks the spot

ButtSharpies, OurUniverse86

I love getting spanked while sir crams in the Sharpies. Pink ass and a hole in training.

ButtSharpies, OurUniverse86

I love being a Sharpied and spanked school girl for Sir ?

ButtSharpies, OurUniverse86

Five is a start isn't it?

ButtSharpies, AnalGW, u_TheOneNotOne

A sharpie makes me wet

ButtSharpies, gonewild, PetiteGoneWild, anal, analgonewild, u_mavi80

(f)eeling two to start (oc)

ButtSharpies, AnalGW, u_gyzor

just the one red [oc]

ButtSharpies, NotADildo, throwaway855836

[F18] made it to 10!! ? it feels so good

ButtSharpies, gonewild, kinksters_gone_wild, SharpieChallenge

[OC] She got to two

ButtSharpies, Anal_Babes, Anal_xxx, AnalAction, AnalGoddess, CHIsuburbsGW, Objects, YourAnalBabes, Slut, assholegonewild, LabiaGW, beef_flaps, insertions, GodPussy, GodAsshole, chubby, AnalGW, buttplug, anal, buttsthatgrip, IWantAnal, NSFW_ANALQUEENS, analgonewild

[F]irst post. Was told this belongs here

ButtSharpies, AnalGW

Kawabanga

ButtSharpies, NSFWdistributor, AdorableOnlyfans

[OC] A spoonful of porn helps the sharpies go in

ButtSharpies, u_BlaBlaBla1913

Two is company ? [oc]

ButtSharpies, u_cooptroop5566

[oc]

ButtSharpies, u_FreeRidersCrew

5 [oc]

ButtSharpies, u_TheOneNotOne

Her first jumbo sharpie for daddy?. She’s been a good girl today and let me share this with you all [OC]

ButtSharpies, u_c1Edward

See how wet this gets me? ? [oc]

ButtSharpies, grool

Only 2 better, but 11 for my 2nd attempt [oc]

ButtSharpies, u_c1Edward, u_ghostweiner77

3 is a lucky number, right? [oc]

ButtSharpies, popolecken

Crayola and curiosity took my anal virginity ? 2 in a 19F

ButtSharpies, gonewild

7 [oc]

ButtSharpies, u_sterling6archer9

Wanted to give this a try, I'm tight in the back! [OC]

ButtSharpies, insertions, Objects

2 [oc]

ButtSharpies, u_asslover81

Soo I got my brother to help me and he was able to fit 5 in my butthole. I know I know I'm a slut but we're all crazy here haha

ButtSharpies, Slut, Amateurincest, assholegonewild, nsfw, gonewild, PetiteGoneWild, LegalTeens, Amateur, BreedingMaterial, anal, asstastic, worldpolitics

We've got a blue sharpie

ButtSharpies, lanarhoades

Managed 5 with my brother's help. Yes I know I know, I don't care if you think I'm nasty haha.

ButtSharpies, assholegonewild, collegesluts, asshole, GWAustralia

11 of whatever the hell the goal is. Another day another sharpie. She loves feedback

ButtSharpies, analgonewild, assholegonewild