Jizz

Hey, Reddit! My boyfriend surprised me by putting a topless girl calendar in my room. I modified it. (NSFW)

pics

{2 of 5} I'll be gone [f]or 10 days starting now. Surprise me with some Karma and I'll make a GINORMOUS album for my return!

gonewild

My morning posts got the mister so (f)ucking horny, he surprised me by coming home early from work, ripping my pants down and doing this. And that was just the warm up. Want to see more?

gonewild

Oh! You surprised me! I was just doing some gardening...

tightdresses

My wife (/u/penthesileia) surprised me on my lunch break.

wifesharing, Hotwife

My boyfriend surprised me with a 3-on-1 play session with some friends. This is what happened to my ass :) [f]

BDSMGW

My wedding planner surprised me with our cake topper last night.

familyguy

My Sister surprises me sometimes!

wincest

My little slutwife surprised me with a couple of screenshots today.

Hotwife

Girlfriend got new thigh highs and surprised me with this. Nsfw

feet

My niece surprises me sometimes.

wincest

Master surprised me for Valentine's Day

bdsm

Instagram never ceases to surprise me.

trashy

Wow, a perfect open circle! My own puss surprises me.

spreading

She surprised me with a lapdance last night.

gonewildcolor

He surprised me with handcuffs. What a wonderful boy!

gonewildcouples

[M/S;A/N] My mom and aunt surprised me in the shower...

wincest

He surprised me with a corset. I couldn't wait to be fucked in it.

WouldYouFuckMyWife, AmateurCollegeGirls

It still surprises me how big they actually are

lindseypelas

After two years I finally told my gf that I was I to futa and she male porn. That I was also interested in pegging. I just went out of town and she surprised me with this picture.

HiddenStrapon

Mum surprised me with this badge for my jacket and I HAD to share it with you guys!! Slightly [NSFW]

Rabbits

My dirty little slut surprised me today with this picture o[F] her tits in a new bra

mycleavage, GoneMild, BustyPetite, palegirls

Waiting with my eyes closed. Surprise me.

facedownassup

[b/s] it honestly surprised me

wincest

My Dom surprised me with a new harness

bdsm

My wi(f)e surprising me this morning.

gonewild

I love when sis surprises me in the bathroom.

IncestGifs

Open invitation... surprise me!

BBWGW

Fucked my wife really well after she surprised me with herself fully shaved. Album and video links in comments.

creampies

Doesn't surprise me

ImGoingToHellForThis

My girlfriend surprised me yesterday, now she wants to be shared

GirlsInDiapers

He asked which hole, she said "surprise me."

milf

Wife Surprised me with a New Toy

WouldYouFuckMyWife, wifesharing, buttplug, pussy, nsfw, Innies

santa really surprised me this year ? [F+M]

GWCouples

She surprised me at work with this picture

Hotwife

[F] What if you surprised me posing this way ?

BustyPetite

Always surprises me what kind of stuff you can find in the depths of your image library if you just look around a bit

FemBoys

Pillars of Eternity II Deadfire surprised me with this

ConfusedBoners

Just got my “surprise me” s/s Stan!! I am thrilled with the color, and it only took a week to ship!

BadDragon

I finally got my “Surprise Me” M/S Crackers in the mail! I’m so happy with how it turned out, I’m OBSESSED with the base colors and the subtle fade and sparkle of the shaft!

BadDragon, VerticalGifs

She surprised me this Black Friday weekend!

Hotwife

(FM41) She surprised me with a late night visit

GWCouples

My cousin always surprises me with the best gifts.

TheFamilyTrap

Will you surprise me one more time?

ChurchOfTifa

POV: you come home early & surprise me [f]

altgonewild

Slavewife surprised me with the artistic flair her line writing had.

BratLife

Wife surprised me with her plump cunt.. Had to share

pussypump

No matter how many times this happens it always surprises me when I find my panties like this in such a state :P

DirtyPantiesGW

My wife does like to surprise me!

SwingerCaptions, u_DoctorDeveon, whoreinurlife