Jizz

I don't even think that's a Sharpie!

ButtSharpies

I like bigger things, but a sharpie will do...

ButtSharpies

Not a sharpie, but close enough.

ButtSharpies

3 sharpies in the butt

ButtSharpies

[F] drawing with a sharpie

gonewild

Just a marker, not a Sharpie:(

ButtSharpies

What should I do with this Sharpie? [f]

gonewild

(F)un with sharpies - A quote she said tonight

gonewild

More pics [f]or you guys... teasing myself with a Sharpie

GoneWildPlus

Just did this with 4 sharpies, 3 safety pins, glue and a ballpoint pen, whatcha think?

MakeupAddiction

So, is the brown sharpie in the butt a coincidence?? (F) (x-post from /r/buttsharpies)

gonewild

Hog Tied [F]or Sharpie & Spanking

ButtSharpies

I just put seven sharpies up my ass ;) think I can fit more?

Sissies

I don't (f)uck around with Sharpies. ;)

gonewild

maybe an album in the near [f]uture with Sharpies? (;

gonewild

Never tried sharpies before. How'd I do?

ButtSharpies

13 sharpies in my pussy

gonewildcurvy

Sorry guys I didn't have any sharpies so I had to make do ;)

GoneWildPlus

A nice sized sharpie, (f)or a nice sized ass.

gonewild

G[F]s ass with a sharpie.

gonewild, GonewildPorn

[Spoilers] Did some fan art with a sharpie

OnePiece

Why I Can Never Find My Sharpies

Amateur, anal, all_nsfw_gifs

(F)eeling blue that my sharpie doodle is washing away

gonewild

Gf sharpies

ForeignObjectsGW

[F]at Sharpie ;)

anal, gonewildcurvy, gonewild, NotADildo, SharpieChallenge

I (25/f) made myself cum with a sharpie

CamSluts, HotCams

[photo] geez, where did i put my sharpie? #kegels

MaxineSapphire

[OC] My Butt Sharpie

RealGirls, 18_24, Gonewilds_Secret, GonewildPlug, ButtSharpies

Butt Sharpie

GoneWildTrans

I stuck a Sharpie in my ass for science [F]

insertions, CuteLittleButts

I stuck a sharpie in my ass [F]

gonewild

Having [M]ore [F]un with u/msskittyfantastico and sharpie

BDSMGW

a sharpie in her butt

Brownasshole

a sharpie in her butt

DarkBitsNPieces, ButtSharpies

Untitled, watercolor and sharpie, me.

Watercolor

she put a sharpie up her ass

kinky, ButtSharpies

a sharpie in her butt

NSFWToys

[F] Mistress has edged me for 3 days and escalated my anal training from sharpies to dildos

gonewild, dykesgonewild, AnalGW

No sharpie needed

Weakpots

A Reddit user is adding one additional sharpie per day in her ass for the entire month of August. (NSFW)

awfuleverything

Day 6 Sharpie Challenge!!! Apologize for the delay

SharpieChallenge

Fun w/ Sharpies! Translation?

AsianGuysNSFW