Jizz

Why yes I would love a peanut butter popcorn sandwich..

holyjesus

My ex 5.... Wanted to play poker. I suggested the peanut butter adhesive

nsfw

Happy Birthday Dirty Bitch! Who wants to play the peanut butter ga[m]e?

gonewild

I've suddenly become allergic to peanut butter...

funny

Peeled off my peanut butter cup's wrapper, and got this dude..

mildlyinteresting

MRW I find that one nut in the jar of creamy peanut butter [NSFW]

reactiongifs

Butter-Sauteed Chicken Breasts with Ghetto-Style Peanut-Thai Ramen

drunkencookery

Messy with Peanut Butter & Jelly with Asian Tgirl Diane

WetAndMessy

Might just have to give it to this peanut butter.

funny

Trying to convince me that carrots with peanut butter is a good idea.... I see something different!

funny

Thick as peanut butter.

thick

Does peanut butter make you fat?

StuffersMale

I'm not sure I want peanut butter anymore...

funny

Just told my 65yo color blind dad that peanut butter is actually brown.

reactiongifs

Molded buttholes. I'm requesting a center fill of peanut-butter to simulate a healthy shit, caramel for diarrhea, and cherry syrup for hemorrhoids.

ImGoingToHellForThis

Fucking peanut butter

WTF

Thicker than peanut butter

pawg, thick

Beards and boners go together like peanut butter and jelly....or jam if you want it to be ;)

Beardsandboners

Let’s see...marshmallow, caramel, peanuts, and whipped butter

areolas

Just like peanut butter goes with jelly....Titties go with Tuesdays! Are you hungry now for PBJ or some TT&Me? ❤️❤️❤️ (F43)

Nebraskanudes

NSFW Peanut Butter Penis

mildlyinteresting, namesforyourpenis

Diane and Mr Peanut Butter, from Bojack Horseman.

MatingPress