Jizz

First Post, longtime lurker. Not gay but very curious.

GaybrosGoneWild

Im not gay but lately I've been thinking about fucking a nice perky butt.

GaybrosGoneWild

I'm not gay but this did well on lbgw so I hope y'all enjoy it aswell

GaybrosGoneWild

It's not gay if it's a threeway

NSFW_China

"GODDAMMIT ASHLEY I'M NOT GAY!" Anyone have the colored version of this Strider Orion piece?

gfur

I'm not gay but thought you would enjoy how I look

gaycumsluts

It's not gay if the balls don't touch

PublicBoys

It's not gay to share a pocket pussy

Bisexy, jobuds

I'm not gay, but here's my cumshot from 10 minutes ago.

GayGifs

"I'm not gay but my boyfriend is."

SexShows

It's not gay if you pretend it's my cock

Sissyperfection, bicuckold

It's not gay... as long as our dicks don't touch.

bicuckold

It's not gay if we're still holding our suits, right?

MensHighJinx

Glad I'm not gay

ImGoingToHellForThis

Anyone wanna do me a solid and suck my dick? It's totally not gay, just two bros helping each other out ;)

TotallyStraight

He's not gay, but still adorable

GaySnapchatImages

LOOK, U DONT HAVE TO WATCH IT BUT STFU IM NOT GAY!!!!1!111!!!!!

THE_PACK

I'm not gay, I just like the attention I get on here

GuysFromBehind

It's not gay! :<

CuteTraps

It's not gay if your ... oops

broslikeus

It's not gay if it makes your GF happy.

jobuds

I'm not gay

lolgrindr

Its not gay if your bottom is castrated

castration

It's not gay

CEIcaptions

Pretty hard to convince myself I'm not gay at this point

sissyhypno

No don't worry, that's not gay !

KinkyCaptions, xxxcaptions, ShemalesParadise

It's not gay... just touch it :)

traps

Its not gay if its a pig and a crocodile [MM] (Clade)

yiff

I'm not gay at all, simply never desired a man, but I would 100% let a guy fuck my ass if it meant me getting to eat out Taylor Swift's at the same time, preferably right after a long concert when she's at her most stinky and delicious.

JerkOffToCelebs

You're not gay, but...

cuckoldcaptions

it's not gay if it's underway

UniformedMen

It's not gay if you say no homo

handholding

(yaoi) Its not gay its manly

BokuNoEroAcademia

He told me he's not gay, but don't worry, he'll let you suck his dick if I make it up to him later

BabeCock

I'm not gay, but I'd probably eat my own ass (HD reupload)

GuysFromBehind, u_Gorgonzola777

It's not gay if I'm wearing gf's fishnets... Or is it ??fuck me either way

FemBoys

It's not gay to cuddle ?

trapsarentgay

It’s not gay if you’re dressed like a girl for him

jobuds

It's not gay if you can't see his face.

BabeCock

It's not gay if it happens in a tent, bro

broslikeus, TotallyStraight

I'm not gay.

traps

just stick it in real quick to make sure I'm not gay haha no homo bro ??

GaybrosGoneWild

It's not gay if I don't show you my dick ?

Sissies, FemBoys, BBCsissies, gonewild, trapsarentgay

Just check to make sure I'm not gay bro

manass

It's not gay if the dudes asshole looks like a pussy right? He's DEFINITELY a popular dude.

TotallyStraight, HunkJunk

It's not gay if your dicks don't touch

broslikeus, TotallyStraight, u_oubilette2

It's not gay, it's just a party

stillstraightcaptions, u_nimblybimbly436, BriesHornyCollection

I'm not gay but I wish I could choke on his cock.

StraightToSissy

I'm not gay but I'm happy to help friends out

stillstraightcaptions, BriesHornyCollection

It's not gay if you're saving water, bro

TotallyStraight, Men2Men, u_918bitony

I swear it's not gay to take me ;)

traps

If he texts saying to come over, you listen. He turned you out after catching you staring in the locker room. You say you’re not gay, but you never miss the chance to let him use you.

straightturnedgay