Jizz

My first bear crush.

gaybears

ok guys, lets see your celebrity crush (he's my first and favorite)

gaybears

She might not be real, but she was MY first redhead crush

redheads

My first redheaded crush...anyone else?

redheads

My first Redhead crush...Ann Margret

redheads

He was my first internet crush

gayteenpics

This was my first celebrity crush ...

gaybears

My first curvy crush: Kerry Marie

curvy

My first celebrity crush

nsfw

As an 80's kid, this was my first celebrity crush ... [fixed]

pics

I had a crush on Stormy when she first hit the scene.

nsfw2

One of my first daddy crushes

GayDaddiesPics

My first teen crush...[NSFW]

gayporn

My first ginger crush: Sissy Spacek

ginger

My first pornstar crush

nsfw

Angelica Bridges from Batwatch was one of my first redhead crushes.

redheads

Mourning Dress - first latex crush from my youth

ShinyPorn

Tae, my first kpop crush. Those flats, hnnghhh.

kpopfap

My first post, some crushed balls

BDSMGW

I just had a wonderful orgasm to Natalie Portman, my first celeb crush.

CelebrityJOMaterial, JizzedToThis

My first college crush

collegesluts, bestofcollege

Who was your first thick crush?

thick_hentai

One of my first video game crushes: Helena Douglas

gaming

Love jerking it to my first celebrity crush Natasha Henstridge, and her thick, breedable body

JerkOffToCelebs

Shared wife for the first time to a then-virgin friend. He always had a crush on her too

wifesharing, WouldYouFuckMyWife

Throwback Thursday - Monica Brant - one of my first musclegirl crushes

Death_By_SnuSnu, hardbodies

Carrie-Anne moss (Trinity) was my first celeb crush

celebJObuds

My first celeb crush, and I’d still fuck her all these years later.

WrestleFap

Olivia Munn for Playboy...this was my first time seeing her, have been crushing on her ever since

NostalgiaFapping

You had a crush on your colleague since the first day...

SissyCensoredPorn

So one of my friends has an insanely cute/hot older sister that all the other guys in our group have a crush on. We made a bet a while ago for who could get with her first. My friend just sent me this through snapchat. Looks like he won... the lucky basta

WhiteAndThick

Layla has me hard as hell, and moaning her name. She was one of my first wrestling crushes.

WrestleFap

It's the first Woman Crush Wednesday of 2019

ZiaFox

I've got a big crush on this girl at my school. My bully found out and got a date with her on his first try after i've been trying for weeks. I've still got a chance though, right? He's 6'6, 220 and is the linebacker on the football team. I'm 5'5, 130 and

bangmybully

Alyssa Milano was my first celeb crush and I still cum to her

JerkOffToCelebs

Mila Kunis, my first non animated lesbian crush

JerkOffToCelebs

Faye Valentine was my first anime/cartoon crush as a kid [Cowboy Bebop]

ecchi

Monica Bellucci is a gorgeous, beautiful woman who was my first celebrity crush - I'd love to have this ultimate MILF teach me a thing or two about making love

JerkOffToCelebs

Monica Brant - vintage hardbody & my first muscle girl crush

hardbodies

Madison Stone. Her and Raven were pretty much my first porn crushes...

NostalgiaFapping

Confessed to by her crush. First date went great. How could things get any better? [implied blowjob] [size]

VanillaCaptions

Shannon Long - My First Playboy Crush

NostalgiaFapping

One of my first Celebrity Crushes, Shakira still has it

JerkOffToCelebs

You loved possessing all of your friends' girlfriends and crushes when you knew they'd be spending time together. At first, they were absolutely livid, but once you started to show them your "skills", they started to look forward to it. Whenever you took

AnimePossession

[f]Can I be your first college crush this year?

GoneMild, UnderwearGW, mycleavage

My cousin had gone behind my back and offered to permanently trade bodies with you, my best friend. At first, I was completely lost.. Why would you offer to take the body of my secret crush? But as soon as you cornered me in an empty classroom at the end

AnimePossession

Alyson was my first celebrity crush. Who was yours?

BabeCock

Jessie Volt & Candee Licious in VR scene "My First Lesbian Crush"

pornVRbest, JessieVolt, CandeeLicious

Who was your first hair crush? Man/Woman, Long/Short? Here is mine...Josie Bissett ?

hairfetish