Jizz

a gi(f) for GW. best caption gets a surprise ;)

gonewild

I gave my mother quite the surprise.

Incest_Captions

I put captions on a Grump video and it was surprisingly accurate at first.

gamegrumps

[Anime] "Let's Play: Milibun!" (Large album, read captions, you'll be surprised)

furry

Surprise

Incest_Captions

[PAID] $10 My dad’s birthday is in two weeks and I’m want to surprise him with a custom shirt. If someone could please put a butt sitting on his head that matches the style and put a red caption that runs just under his chin that says ‘FINALLY, A HAT THAT

PhotoshopRequest

Valentine's Day Caption - Surprising Your Girlfriend [Female, Girlfriend, Cleavage, Skimpy Towel]

hentaicaptions

Miley Cyrus has a little surprise for her dad. (Anyone interested in a mix of celebs and wincest captions?)

wincest

Sent pics to someone to get them captioned as a surprise for hubby [F]

assholegonewild, RealGirls, SpreadEm, EdibleButtholes, slutwife, wifesharing, NaughtySlutWife, NaughtyWives, asstastic, asshole, CurvesAreAwesome, WouldYouFuckMyWife, u_Illustrious-Affect25

Nym Fleurette - Cuckold birthday surprise. Story/captions in album attached.

cuckoldcaptions

[F/d] Birthday Surprise

Incest_Captions, taboocaptions

I said at? I meant on... your in for big surprise [cheating][gif]

xxxcaptions, Incest_Captions, u_investing1233456

Your wife never had many male friends so it surprised you

NSFW_Caption, xxxcaptions, CheatingCaptions, cheatingwives, AsianCuckoldCaptions

Surprised

Vindictive_Captions, keyholdercaptions

What's part 2? That's a surprise. A thick, creamy surprise.

NSFW_Caption, CheatingCaptions, cuckoldcaptions, xxxcaptions, u_nimblybimbly436, u_kingpinddxx, u_pitchardg

She said she has a surprise for you but you couldn't guessed what it is

xxxcaptions, Incest_Captions, IncestFlixxx, IncestClub

Surprise for her at work!

UnfilteredCaptions, NSFW_Caption

"Oh no! Another surprise penis!" - If I had to caption this

jennahaze, u_furver91

Mom's Birthday Surprise

Incest_Captions

Mom and Sister's Welcome Home Surprise

Incest_Captions, u_Otherwise_Mouse_8884, HentaiHorseCock