Jizz

Needs a peanutbutter and crisco sandwich or three.

nsfw

White Chocolate and peanutbutter

lesbians

Beautiful Olivia Wilde close up | 3 Men eating peanutbutter out of each others assholes

FiftyFifty

I have a chocolate peanutbutter treat for you

dicks

Introducing: The Creamy Peanutbutter then Cheese then Ham then Crunchy Peanutbutter Sandwhich. Heated.

shittyfoodporn

Peanutbutter Paws [F] (by Antiroo)

Footpaws

Peanutbutter (f)

gonewild

More peanutbutter! (f)

gonewild

Peanutbutter (f)

gonewild

Peanutbutter (f)

gonewild

Someone made a statue of Mr Peanutbutter drinking coffee in the nude

BoJackHorseman

Diane Nguyen, BoJack Horseman, Mr. Peanutbutter (KassMonday, Mr. Hankey's) [BoJack Horseman]

rule34

Mr. Peanutbutter & BoJack Horseman (Bikomation)

gfur

Mr. Peanutbutter (Drofox)

gfur, Bojackhorsemen

Foals Overboard (peanutbutter)

fluffycommunity

Mr. Peanutbutter (jrjresq)

gfur

Bojack & Mr. Peanutbutter (Bikomation)

gfur, Bojackhorsemen, Creamypeanutbutter